PORTSMOUTH, Ohio — Most date nights make you pick: dinner, or something to do after dinner. Oddfellows, in an 1852 building in Portsmouth’s Boneyfiddle District, put the whole evening under one roof. Wood-fired pizza, duckpin bowling, a vintage arcade that costs nothing to play, and live music, all in the same night out.

First time at duckpin? You’re the target audience
Duckpin bowling uses smaller pins and smaller balls, and most people who walk in have never tried it. Owner Maddie Kehoe-Burnside says that is half the fun. First dates, families with little kids, and groups of adults who get far more competitive than they planned all end up on the lanes, and nobody has to be any good at it to have a good time.

The fall menu leans cozy
The kitchen is getting ready to roll out its fall and winter menu, bringing back favorites and adding a few new things. The homemade French onion and potato soups are back, alongside the Hot Honey and Goat Cheese pizza that regulars ask about, smoked wings, and a cedar-planked salmon Kehoe-Burnside calls a must-try. Nearly everything coming out of the kitchen is made from scratch, and the menu takes familiar foods and puts the house spin on them.

A building, and a promise
The building itself dates to 1852, and it came to the family through her late husband, Jeremy Burnside, who had the idea of buying it along with three neighboring buildings in the Boneyfiddle. During development, Jeremy was diagnosed with a rare form of brain cancer, and he died in 2022 before he could see Oddfellows finished.
Kehoe-Burnside thought about walking away. She stayed with it because the project had meant so much to him, and somewhere along the way it became about more than opening a restaurant. Her husband, Jay, a builder who also works the kitchen, helped her bring it to life.
“It’s not really about pizza or bowling,” she said. “It’s about having a place where people can make memories together.”
The perfect fall evening, her way
Asked to script the ideal night, Kehoe-Burnside starts with a cocktail and something good to eat, then a competitive game of duckpin, a round of the free arcade games, and staying late enough to catch whatever live music or event is on that night. People come in for dinner, she said, and end up staying all evening, because there is no reason to rush off somewhere else to find something fun to do.
Oddfellows is in the Boneyfiddle District of downtown Portsmouth. Menus and event nights are at pizzasandpins.com.
Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com.
Get the morning stories.
Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com, or use the contact page.
This WeekScioto County archive
Best way to eat a garden tomato?
Today's question. Five seconds to vote, all day to argue about it.
Cast your voteLocal trivia and strong opinions, a new question every day. No sign-up, just vote.
Latest bookings

Vinton County
Kindria Ellen Rinehart
Booked Nov 16, 2026

Vinton County
Franklin Ryan Pierce
Booked Nov 15, 2026

Vinton County
James David Black
Booked Nov 11, 2026
Individuals are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.











