CHILLICOTHE, Ohio — Two men were arrested Tuesday afternoon after Chillicothe police responded to a reported robbery in progress at Sherman Park, according to police and jail records.
The Chillicothe Police Department report states officers were dispatched to 801 Sherman Park shortly after 11:18 a.m. on September 23 for a possible robbery in progress. The incident was ultimately classified as aggravated robbery, a first-degree felony under Ohio law.
According to the report, the alleged offense involved a shotgun and a blunt object. The report also indicates the incident was drug-related. Police listed the offense as completed and noted that no forced entry occurred.
Multiple Chillicothe police officers and a medic responded to the scene. An initial narrative from Officer Christopher Althouse states he was dispatched to Sherman Park for the possible robbery and that the investigation continued.
Jail records show Trey Allan Brushart, 21, and Keith Alan Scaggs II, 39, were subsequently booked into the Ross County Jail on first-degree felony aggravated robbery charges.
Brushart was booked at approximately 1:32 p.m., while Scaggs was booked at approximately 2:01 p.m. Both jail entries identify the Chillicothe Police Department as the arresting agency and Officer Monique Lee as the arresting officer. Both were initially listed as being held without bond.
The police report lists the case as cleared by adult arrest.
The publicly available report is marked as an unapproved draft, and the narrative provided does not yet detail what police allege occurred during the robbery or the specific actions attributed to each defendant.
Both men are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.
Also booked
Safer Ohio: Columbus Man Booked Into Ross County Jail on Drug Trafficking,…
Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com.
Get the morning stories.
Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com, or use the contact page.
How many times was Chillicothe Ohio's state capital?
Today's question. Five seconds to vote, all day to argue about it.
Cast your voteLocal trivia and strong opinions, a new question every day. No sign-up, just vote.
Latest bookings
Vinton County
James David Black
Booked Nov 11, 2026
Vinton County
Harold Dean Withrow
Booked Nov 4, 2026
Vinton County
Gale Phillip Misner
Booked Nov 3, 2026
Individuals are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
