Late-night brawl outside Circleville bar on East Main Street ends in arrest, assault charges still under review

- Advertisement -Advertisement

Pickaway County

CIRCLEVILLE, Ohio. A fight outside a bar on East Main Street early Saturday, Oct. 3, ended with one man in handcuffs, and Circleville police say assault charges are still under investigation.

James Adam Haughey, 34, of Circleville, was arrested and booked into the Pickaway County Jail on a charge of disorderly conduct while intoxicated, according to the Circleville Police Department report.

Haughey has pleaded not guilty, according to Circleville Municipal Court records. A pretrial hearing is set for Nov. 4.

Officers were dispatched around 2:29 a.m. to Tootles on East Main Street for a report of a fight. According to the report, an officer had removed Haughey from the bar and warned him about disorderly conduct around 2:10 a.m., about 20 minutes earlier. A bartender told police the trouble started when she refused to serve him a double shot.

Witnesses gave officers different accounts of what happened next. Several people at the scene told police Haughey punched a woman in the face and hit a man in the chest, and two of them called him the main aggressor. One woman told officers Haughey tackled her when she walked over to check on a woman who was with him.

Haughey told officers he was defending himself and that he had been pulled to the ground and hit and choked. He showed officers scrapes on his legs. The woman with him said the other group started the fight while the two of them were waiting for a ride.

According to the report, Haughey grabbed an officer’s hand twice while the officer was trying to keep him back, and was handcuffed. Police wrote that he was belligerent and shouted insults at officers while he was in the cruiser and later at the hospital, where he refused treatment.

Officers photographed injuries at the scene. The report says the assault charges are pending further investigation, and police have requested surveillance video from a nearby bank.

Charges are allegations, not a conviction. Haughey is innocent until proven guilty.

Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com.

Get the morning stories.

- Advertisement -Advertisement

Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com, or use the contact page.

Ross County bookings at 7 a.m. Name, charge, town.

Text me the morning list. Reply STOP to quit.
HOMETOWN POLL

Best way to eat a garden tomato?

Today's question. Five seconds to vote, all day to argue about it.

Cast your vote

Local trivia and strong opinions, a new question every day. No sign-up, just vote.

Latest bookings

  • Booking photo of Kindria Ellen Rinehart

    Vinton County

    Kindria Ellen Rinehart

    Booked Nov 16, 2026

  • Booking photo of Franklin Ryan Pierce

    Vinton County

    Franklin Ryan Pierce

    Booked Nov 15, 2026

  • Booking photo of James David Black

    Vinton County

    James David Black

    Booked Nov 11, 2026

All mugshots

Individuals are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

- Advertisement -Advertisement
- Advertisement -Advertisement

More articles

- Advertisement -Advertisement
- Advertisement -Advertisement

Latest article

Today's Poll