Why Your Heating Bill Jumps Faster Than the Temperature Falls

- Advertisement -Advertisement

Be the first to weigh in

Every winter, the same thing happens in homes across southern Ohio. The temperature drops some, and the heating bill jumps a lot. We asked Dr. Gabriel Lade, an energy economist at Ohio State University, to explain why that happens and what actually brings a bill down. Dr. Lade is an associate professor and holds the C. William Swank Chair in Rural-Urban Policy. He answered our questions by email, using Columbia Gas of Ohio rates as his running example.

When a cold snap settles over southern Ohio, why does a family’s heating bill climb so much faster than the temperature falls?

What drives your bill is not the temperature itself, but how far it sits below about 65 degrees, or wherever you set your thermostat. Utilities and forecasters measure that gap in “heating degree days,” and gas use rises roughly in step with it.

A simple example: a week averaging 45 degrees means a 20-degree gap each day. A week averaging 15 degrees means a 50-degree gap. The thermometer dropped 30 degrees, but the furnace has to do two and a half times the work. For a typical home on today’s Columbia rates, that is the difference between roughly $18 and $45 in gas usage for the week.

Price can stack on top of that. Columbia’s default gas price jumped about 35 percent for February 2026 after last winter’s cold, so a cold week at a winter-peak price can cost about four times as much as a mild week. One nuance: Columbia’s default price is set before each month begins, so a surprise mid-month cold snap mostly raises the bill through how much gas you burn. The price effect tends to show up the following month.

Ohio produces a great deal of natural gas from shale. Why does that not protect Ohio households when winter gas prices spike?

Natural gas trades in a national market connected by pipelines and, increasingly, by export terminals. Gas at Ohio and Appalachian wells often sells for somewhat less than the national benchmark because pipeline space out of the region is tight, but households do not see that discount. Columbia’s default rate is the national NYMEX benchmark price plus an adder set at auction, so when national prices spike, Ohio bills follow. That said, shale has helped lower gas prices for all of the U.S. over the past 15 years. It just does not give Ohioans a special local price.

Many of our readers heat with propane or heating oil delivered by truck, and others rely on electric heat. How do price swings for those fuels compare with natural gas during a cold winter?

Propane and heating oil are sold by unregulated dealers, so unless you have locked in a price, wholesale swings tend to reach customers quicker. Gas and electric delivery charges are set by regulators and change slowly, though the default price for the gas itself resets every month. Which fuel spikes varies from year to year. Last winter, Ohio propane held fairly steady while Columbia’s default gas price jumped 35 percent in a single month. This fall, heating oil is the fuel that has surged, from what I have seen.

Overall, natural gas is still the cheapest way to heat a home in Ohio. By my rough calculation, counting everything on a typical gas bill, propane costs about twice as much as gas for the same warmth, heating oil about three times, and electric baseboard or resistance heat three to four times. Heat pumps come out close in cost, though they lose efficiency in deep cold.

How much of a typical Ohio winter heating bill is the fuel itself, and how much is delivery charges and fees that a household cannot shop around or control?

Roughly half of a typical winter gas bill is delivery charges and fees. Columbia customers pay about $57 a month in fixed charges before they burn any gas, plus per-unit delivery charges on top of the gas itself. On current rates, the gas itself is roughly 40 to 50 percent of a winter bill, and a smaller share in milder months, when the fixed charges dominate. Those fixed charges have been rising under a rate increase regulators approved in 2023, which the Ohio Supreme Court upheld this past June.

Readers hear advice about budget billing, lowering the thermostat, and switching gas or electric suppliers through Ohio’s Energy Choice program. Which of those save real money over a whole winter, and which ones mostly move the cost around?

Budget billing saves nothing. It spreads the same cost evenly across the year.

Turning down the thermostat saves real money, because it shrinks the gap the furnace has to make up. On a 30-degree day, lowering the thermostat three degrees cuts gas use by roughly 9 percent. The savings apply only to the gas you burn, not to the fixed charges.

Switching suppliers through Energy Choice is where people can lose money. The Ohio Consumers’ Counsel, the state’s utility consumer advocate, estimated in 2022 that Columbia customers who shopped had paid about $2 billion more over two decades than those on the default rate. On the electric side, an Ohio State study found that about seven in ten 12-month fixed offers were priced above the utility’s default rate. A fixed-rate contract can win in a winter like the last one, but on average it has not. My advice to readers: compare any offer against the utility’s Standard Choice Offer on the state’s Energy Choice Ohio website, and be wary of introductory rates that roll over to higher variable prices. That is where most people lose through Energy Choice, in my read, since they forget to check back in after taking a generous introductory rate.

Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com.

Get the morning stories.

- Advertisement -Advertisement

Send a tip or correction to info@heritageheadlines.com, or use the contact page.

HOMETOWN POLL

The great Logan Elm stood in which county?

Today's question. Five seconds to vote, all day to argue about it.

Cast your vote

Local trivia and strong opinions, a new question every day. No sign-up, just vote.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

You need to be signed in to comment.

New here? Create a free account. It only takes a minute.

Be the first to weigh in

Latest bookings

  • Booking photo of Jadie Brook Caudill

    Vinton County

    Jadie Brook Caudill

    Booked Nov 18, 2026

  • Booking photo of Tyler Ernest Lee Moore

    Vinton County

    Tyler Ernest Lee Moore

    Booked Nov 18, 2026

  • Booking photo of Kindria Ellen Rinehart

    Vinton County

    Kindria Ellen Rinehart

    Booked Nov 16, 2026

All mugshots

Individuals are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

- Advertisement -Advertisement
- Advertisement -Advertisement

More articles

- Advertisement -Advertisement
- Advertisement -Advertisement

Latest article

Today's Poll